Hierarchy of Battery System Design

Level 2 Battery System (Hierarchy of Battery System Design 2.0)

Battery Management Systems (and the Insurance Industry)

Interested in understanding battery system project risk and how to assess it? Please join me in Las Vegas on December 7th for a 4-hour, PDH-eligible course at 2015 Renewable Energy World.

I recently revised the Hierarchy of Battery System Design. This short series explores each level through one or more examples.

Read about Level 1, Level 2, Level 3, Level 4, and Level 5 systems.

A simple battery system is comprised of battery cells plus a management system. The big innovation of Level 2 is introducing a battery management system (BMS) with simple control loops that senses specific outputs from within the battery system and alters performance using a limited set of actions. The control loops are necessary in order to increase the safety and longevity of battery systems constructed with advanced battery cells such as Lithium ion.

Level 2 battery systems enjoy improved longevity and safety as a direct result of the addition of a battery management system to improve battery system performance. The control loops of a Level 2 BMS recognize two states, Good-Bad. When a Bad state exists, the battery system is placed in a non-operating and/or degraded state with the intent to halt a potentially damaging situation and preserve the battery system for use at a later time. As you might imagine, this approach causes problems when the system is part of a vehicle in motion or integrated into a renewable energy system that is contracted to provide ancillary services or power and energy to a schedule.

When the Kahuku Wind Farm on the island of Oahu, Hawaii went into service in 2011, it did so with an advanced Lead acid battery system as an integral part of the project. In Months 2 and 3 of the the project’s operations phase, battery system fires interrupted operations. A final fire, in August 2012, led to a $30 million loss and operations were halted for 18 months until a new (non-battery) technology could be put in place. The battery system developer indicated that the fires all started with the inverter technology used in the battery system project.

Level 2 battery systems typically displace battery management system construction and/or risk to a third-party player by engaging a third-party developer or a commercial off-the-shelf (COTS) battery management system.

This third-party approach segregates battery management risk from the battery system developer. When looking for information about the battery management system for Kahuku Wind Farms, it is evident that the inverters were custom electronics specific to this advanced Lead acid battery technology. Changes were made, at the direction of the battery system developer, to the inverter’s construction and functionality to accommodate the advanced Lead acid batteries.

Insurance industry player Lloyd’s of London paid out claims in excess of $2 million dollars for multiple claims as a result of the Kahuku Wind Farms battery system fires. Subsequently, certain underwriters filed suit against companies associated with the construction and supply of the inverters for the Kahuku Wind Farm battery system. The Underwriters’ lawsuit against companies other than the battery system developer could be taken to indicate that the segregating BMS risk approach has validity. My opinion is that that these types of lawsuits will evolve as the insurance industry’s involvement with commercial battery system projects expands.

A Level 2 battery system can do well in applications which are simple (such as an off-grid street lamp which discharges overnight and charges during the day) and/or that are tightly constrained to a few known states, especially when unknown states typically mean a loss of the entire application so the battery system functionality during such states is not mission-critical (such as a satellite).

The concept that battery system developers are in the best position to manage battery management system design and implementation distinguishes a Level 3 battery system from a Level 2 system where subsystems of the battery system are treated as interchangeable parts. Due to the complexity of the electric grid and the limitations of a Level 2 BMS, a Level 2 battery system is unsuitable for a utility-scale applications.

As we go higher in battery system level, a more sophisticated approach that includes an awareness of commercial risk and opportunity becomes increasingly central. With Level 3 battery systems, development is driven by:

(a) the need for more sophisticated control loop states and actions in order to carry out battery system functions;

(b) the desire to include entire subcomponents of the battery system design in the risk mitigation strategy to unlock bigger market opportunities by enabling warranties to be made.


Send to Kindle
Hierarchy of Battery System Design

Level 1 Battery System (Hierarchy of Battery System Design 2.0)

Sometimes a battery is just a bunch of batteries Interested in understanding battery system project risk and how to assess it? Please join me in Las Vegas on December 7th for a 4-hour, PDH-eligible course at 2015 Renewable Energy World. I recently revised the Hierarchy of Battery System Design. This short series explores each level […]

Hierarchy of Battery System Designs version 2.0

Leveling Up, Hierarchy of Battery System Designs 2.0

Classifying battery system designs Interested in understanding battery system project risk and how to assess it? Please join me in Las Vegas on December 7th for a 4-hour, PDH-eligible course at 2015 Renewable Energy World. In early 2014 I published a work-in-progress called the Hierarchy of Battery System Design. It was an attempt to codify […]

Financing Battery Systems, Part II

Tackling battery system commercialization I published a short post on LinkedIn about a structural challenge in renewable energy, specifically energy storage. In summary, advanced energy storage has been in development for decades now, yet we are still seeing non-economic deals and demonstration projects. I’ve written before about the information asymmetry in this industry and while […]

Vintage Radio Batteries by France1978 at Flickr

Information asymmetry in energy storage: implications for battery system costs

First published on LinkedIn on 03 April 2015 Energy storage costs March 2015 at Electroferocious looked at information asymmetry in energy storage markets as a mechanism that increases project costs and threatens grid reliability, resilience, and security. System costs It’s difficult to get real numbers about energy storage system costs, and yet that is just […]

WP Title - Understanding Electricity Costs

A brief exploration of electricity costs

If you haven’t already, I invite you to play with the Battery System Pricing calculator. It allows you to determine the per kilowatt and per kilowatt-hour pricing of a system as well as a rough estimate of the cost of delivered electricity. Evaluating both power and energy pricing makes it easier to compare different battery […]

Pricing grid energy storage: power vs energy

Should energy storage costs be $/kWh or $/kW?

Pricing conventions for energy storage systems Recently, battery systems have been in the news and on the minds of many. Many in the media have whipped out calculators, but I decided to build one so anyone can compare pricing. The challenge, however, is finding credible information amongst all the hype. Much of the hype centers […]

[Presentation] What is a battery system?

Information about energy storage systems is a popular topic which is why I’ve devoted the month of April to getting back to basics. A few weeks ago I attended the RSA Conference so, in the interest of time, I turned a previous post discussing a few key concepts defining battery systems into a slide deck. […]

Title: What is a battery system?

What is a battery system?

Battery system basics Establishing a common terminology and a few key concepts about battery systems will be useful to the ongoing discussions of performance, security, risk, and design. To facilitate that, I explain two diagrams showing the elements of a battery system and a simple battery system architecture. Send to Kindle

Two Types of Grid-Scale Battery Systems

Two Types of Grid-scale Battery Systems

Battery System Classification Grid-scale battery systems can be broadly classified into two types: AC-side and DC-side battery systems. Addressing project needs for a particular battery system design, its performance and risk, and the associated techno-economic models which can be built comes down to examining their differences. Let’s settle on some basic concepts first by using […]